Do You Talk Too Much Before Trial?

à ¢â‚ ¬œHey, I don’t know if you noticed this or not, but there’s a significant problem with your case. If you don’t do something to fix it, you’re guaranteed to lose. But if you can fix it, your chances of winning will dramatically improve. Do you mind if I tell you what the problem is?à ¢â‚ ¬

If someone made that offer to you, your immediate reaction would probably be, à ¢â‚ ¬œYes, please tell me what’s wrong!à ¢â‚ ¬

What’s surprising is that every day in courthouses around the country, lawyers regularly make offers like that to their opponents and don’t even realize it. For example, many years ago, I was the prosecutor handling a à ¢â‚ ¬œPossession with Intent to Sell” narcotics case. It was a simple possession case (the drugs were found in his pocket), but the defendant insisted that he wanted a trial. I wasn’t the first prosecutor assigned to the case. A previous prosecutor had actually tried the case, but the jury had hung 5-1 in favor of à ¢â‚ ¬œGuilty” so the case had been reset for trial. In the meantime, that prosecutor left our office, so the case fell into my lap. On the day of trial, several other cases on the docket seemed far more important than this one, so I offered the defense attorney a misdemeanor plea offer in hopes that we could resolve it and move on to more important cases.

à ¢â‚ ¬œOh no, that’s not gonna happen,” the attorney replied, à ¢â‚ ¬œHe wants his day in court.à ¢â‚ ¬

That seemed greedy to me, because technically, he’d already had his day in court, and now he was insisting upon a second day, but rather than say anything, I decided to bite my tongue and let the attorney continue talking. He proceeded to tell me what a wonderful attorney he was, how strong his case was, how weak my case was, and then, best of all, he started bragging about how great a job he’d done in the last trial: à ¢â‚ ¬œThe last time we tried this case, your predecessor called three witnesses, and that third guy didn’t even know what hit him. My cross-examination destroyed his credibility. By the time I’m done cross-examining him today, this courtroom is going to be littered with reasonable doubts. I can’t wait to get my hands on that guy again!à ¢â‚ ¬

The urge to interject during his tirade had been nearly overwhelming, but I continued holding my tongue until he’d wrapped up, then politely excused myself to make some last minute preparations for trial.

Jury selection proceeded without incident, and a short while later, we proceeded to opening statements. I delivered a perfunctory opening statement (à ¢â‚ ¬œDrugs… Him… Possess… Thank youà ¢â‚ ¬) and sat down. After he concluded his opening statement, I proceeded to call my first witness, who testified that he’d found a large quantity of suspected drugs in the defendant’s pockets and that the drugs were packaged for sale, rather than personal use.

After he was cross-examined, I called a drug analyst to the stand, who testified about her work in the drug lab and confirmed that the items in evidence were actually narcotics. Her cross-examination was brief, so I decided to waive my re-direct examination. As she stepped down from the witness stand, I saw that the other attorney could barely restrain himself. This was the moment he’d been planning for — the opportunity to rip the next witness to shreds!

People who use drugs, in my opinion, should not be locked up right away; instead, they should be placed in a rehab center to help them recover from their addiction, not just physically but also psychologically. For example, rehab centers such as Arista Recovery in Overland Park are trying to assist people who believe it is acceptable to be addicted to one or more substances. Whereas, I can’t say the same for those who sell drugs or, in my case, have drugs in their pockets. Because I believe strict rules need to be followed when it comes to marketing drugs.

Coming back to the instance I was talking about, once the lab analyst witness left the courtroom, the judge turned to me and said, à ¢â‚ ¬œState, please call your next witness.à ¢â‚ ¬

Rising from my seat, I addressed the courtroom in a loud, clear voice: à ¢â‚ ¬œYour Honor, that concludes the presentation of the State’s evidence, and the State rests its case.à ¢â‚ ¬

The defense attorney’s jaw hit the table in shock. He rushed to sidebar and, in a flabbergasted tone, said, à ¢â‚ ¬œHe… He can’t do that! I planned my entire case around cross-examining that third witness! What am I supposed to do now?!?à ¢â‚ ¬

Volumes could be written about the arguments that followed, but those are stories best shared at some other time, perhaps over a cold beer. Suffice it to say, his case had been torpedoed.

There are two important lessons you need to take away from this story. The first is this: Don’t brag or boast about your case strategies or the strengths and weaknesses of your case.

One of the reasons he lost the case was because of his tremendous ego and his need to boast. When he told me that he’d destroyed the third witness during the previous trial, I re-examined my case plan. I asked myself, à ¢â‚ ¬œDo I really need to call this witness? How much does he add to the case, compared to how much damage he’ll inflict?” I decided that the minor amount of useful information he’d add to the case wasn’t worth the nightmare, and I decided not to call him. If the other’s lawyer’s ego hadn’t pushed him to brag and boast about the case, things might have turned out completely different.

Beware of falling into the same trap.

Since you’re a trial lawyer, your ego is larger than most. It’s nothing to be too embarrassed about — all lawyers have egos. Trial lawyers’ egos are even larger than most, because we live in the high stakes world of à ¢â‚ ¬œwin or go home.” We hate to lose, we love to win, and when we do a great job, we want to tell everybody else what we’ve done. It’s okay to brag, but unfortunately, some lawyers don’t know when to shut their mouths!

To avoid the problem and protect your clients, take a quick history lesson.

Loose Lips Might Sink Ships posterBack during World War II, the War Advertising Council and the Office of War Information (back in the ’40’s, federal agency names weren’t as cute or cryptic as today’s agency names, were they?) created a series of public service ad campaigns designed to remind Americans about the importance of preventing restricted information from being leaked to the enemy. The campaign was so successful that one of the catchphrases has become part of the American lexicon. Even if you weren’t alive when the campaign originally ran (1942-1945), you’re probably familiar with the phrase: à ¢â‚ ¬œLoose Lips Sink Ships.” The lesson was simple: be discreet in your communications, especially when you don’t know who might be listening.

But before you’re tempted to reprint the posters and post them all over your courthouse, think about the second lesson from the story: Keep your ears open and listen.

Your opponents probably love to brag about the strengths of their case or the weaknesses in your case. Next time, rather than disagreeing with them, quietly listen to what they’re saying and encourage them to boast. Play à ¢â‚ ¬œdumb as a post” and see what they say. As the great Yogi Berra said, à ¢â‚ ¬œYou can observe a lot just by watching.” Don’t get drawn into an argument with them trying to justify the strength of your case or dispute the strength of theirs. If they try to pick a fight, just give them noncommittal responses like, à ¢â‚ ¬œYou may be right,” and let them continue boasting. These lessons ideally work whether you’re a felony criminal defense attorney, a divorce lawyer, a bankruptcy lawyer, or whatever it is you fight for; observing and listening could just give you information that you can use, and end up helping more than you realize at court sessions.

You’re trained to battle in the courtroom, so it won’t be easy to suppress your natural instinct to respond in kind, but it’s something you’ll have to do. Then, after they’ve finished boasting, find a way to shore up your weaknesses or better prepare for their strengths. If you do that, then you can brag and boast when it really matters… After you’ve won your case!

Comments policy: Be cool. Uncool things (infantile comments, racist crap, spam links, etc) will be removed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 thoughts on “Do You Talk Too Much Before Trial?

  1. This is an excellent article and is actually applicable not only for trial but during settlement discussions which precede trial; a lot can be learned by just listening observing and then taking action, we in the legal field would do well to observe that premise more often.

    Keep up the good work.

  2. Great article, Elliott! This is something we ALL need to be reminded of on a daily basis. Keep the good ideas coming.

  3. This particular email should be blown up into a Poster and posted in every hallway in offices and courtrooms. It’s such basic information with a potency of message. Thank you for your beautiful brain. RoseAnn